Visitor Reviews
Sanibel Dreams My husband and I spent a week at the Island Inn to celebrate our 10th anniversary. We stayed in the Starkey Lodge and loved it. The room had everything we needed and a beautiful beach view with a screened in porch. The staff had left us towel swans with champagne glasses and a lovely note thanking us for spending our anniversary there. And there was a bottle of champagne in the fridge! What a nice surprise. The staff was so nice and accommodating. The beach was full of shells which made my shell seeker self very happy. We can't wait to go back maybe for our 15th! read more
Love This Place! We had visited the Island Inn a few years ago and were keen to return. It was great to see the resort is well on its way to recovery after hurricane Ian. We stayed in Matthew’s Lodge. The accommodation was top notch, with amazing views. There was still some beach restoration happening but this wasn’t really an issue. The no-see-ums were out in force so bring some bug spray! Staff were fantastic throughout. Looking forward to our next visit! read more
Another memorable stay at the Island Inn! We have been to Island Inn multiple times and couldn't wait to return post Ian. The hurricane may have destroyed parts of this resort, but it certainly did not damper the spirit of the entire staff here. You'd never know Ian blew through the bottom level of Starky Lodge as the renovations are pristine and exactly how we remembered it. The beach is as beautiful as ever, and the shelling was absolutely amazing. The Wednesday morning beach walk by Annie (marine biologist from Sanibel Sea School) was so informative and enjoyable. She was a wealth of knowledge regarding all aspects of sea life and seashells. Although we opted out of housekeeping, their staff was very accommodating in replenishing towels, toiletries and coffee when we ran out. We enjoyed dining at Mudbugs (twice), Green Flash, Timbers and Doc Fords. All of the local shops and restaurants were very appreciative of the business, and it was a pleasure to support them. Thank you, Glory, Ken and Chris for another memorable stay and for your tireless efforts on behalf of this lovely storied resort. We can't wait to return again! read more
